Monday, August 25, 2008

Deseret News Declares War on Legislature

In late-June/early-July, the Deseret News and the Tribune submitted records requests for documents. The Trib’s request was broad. The D News asked for a specific document.

The Trib’s broader request netted documents that led to a story. No documents matched the specific document requested by the D News. John Fellows, legislative general counsel, explained the situation to Lee Davidson of the D News, when Davidson called in a dither. Davidson exploded that Fellows “knew what they wanted.” Fellows explained that all sorts of liability could flow from releasing sensitive documents that were never actually requested. And, I’d imagine that Fellows might have wanted to add that it’s not his job to divine what a big, well-lawyered organization (that trades in words, for heaven’s sake) wanted, despite what it actually requested.

Davidson threatened Fellows, saying that his refusal to relent to the demands of the Deseret News would “constitute a declaration of war.” Fellows told him to redraft his request.

Immediately thereafter, the D News hit the Legislative Office of Research and General Counsel (LRGC) with an unprecedented number of records requests, many of them dealing with – you guessed it – personnel issues involving LRGC.

Last week, the D News ran a story that clearly would reflect poorly on legislative leadership. Problem is, the story was completely made up. In fact, D News editors privately admitted that the story was made up; yet, the D News is still running with the fabricated story.

Don’t mess with Big Media.

10 Comments:

Blogger Brian said...

I'm anxious to hear any response to this from the DNews. A poorly worded GRAMA request which doesn't produce the desired result should not produce declaration of war, but declarations of embarassment for failure to make the proper request.

When GRAMA requests are made, not to inform readers, but to punish and intimidate LRGC staff for not reading minds, there is a problem.

And isn't this Lee Davidson the man who had a rather intense, public confrontation with Senator Bramble during the last legislative session where Davidson refused to shake the Senator's hand? And while Davidson seethed, Sen. Bramble remained curteous and calm? Someone help me out here...

9:22 PM  
Blogger Obi wan liberali said...

Give Joe Cannon a call and see if he can resolve this matter. I'm with you that we should have better transperancy, but given the legislature's record, the argument is getting just a bit old.

I'm all for transparency. As a senate intern back in the 1980's, I used to sneak into the House Republican caucus and was appalled at what nonsense was spewed from the less than intellectually gifted members of that caucus. But lecturing the press about being more transparent should come from something other than a legislator. However, I have little to no influence with Joe Cannon. IRL, he knows who I am, and I, ahem, am not on his "A" list.

Also, we never elected the press. I hold legislators to a higher standard than Bernick, who is just another weak-willed political hack who doesn't know enough to seriously hold legislative leaders accountable. When I knew Bernick, he was awestruck by Republican leaders with great and important titles.

I guess he is no longer awestruck, but his pendancy for inaccuracy doesn't seem to have left him. His slavish praise for former legislative leaders seems to have been replaced inaccurate assumptions about legislative intent.

However, on the bright side, if any legislators seek to amend the laws regarding referendums, I'll be calling on you to stand in opposition to those proposals based upon your posts regarding this matter.

10:40 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bernick and Davidson need to save declarations of war for the United States Congress.

And Brian, I personally saw Davidson's confrontation with Bramble. (So did a KSL cameraman who caught about half of it on film.)

The interesting thing was that despite the Saturday's Vouyer caricature of Bramble as a hothead, he was perfectly polite, calm, cool and collected.

It was Davidson who went nuts. Shaking, yelling and refusing to shake Bramble's hand. Quite frankly it was an embarrassing spectacle.

As expected, the story of this temper tantrum ran all over Capitol Hill and later ended up in Rolly's column.

Once that happend, Davidson's rage was directed at Rolly. Apparently Davidson doesn't like being the subject of a story.

1:16 AM  
Blogger steve u. said...

Obi Wan,

The House is pretty transparent these days. The last 2 sessions (under Curtis's direction), I don't recall closing a caucus other than for 10 minutes a time or two to talk about elections.

And, I have called Cannon. He won't return my call. I must not be on the "A" list either.

8:17 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great work Steve.

These posts are well written and well reasoned.

9:36 AM  
Anonymous Tom Grover said...

Great work Steve.

Keep up the good work.

9:37 AM  
Blogger Obi wan liberali said...

I'm glad to hear about the increased transparency. Though I'm not hopeful that Joe Cannon will put me on his A list, there is hope he'll remove the restraining order. :)

9:52 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

They have to attract readers Steve, any way they can. Look at the latest from the NYTimes.

New York Times Co. said Tuesday that its July revenue from continuing operations fell 10.1 percent this year as advertising revenue slipped 16.2 percent.
Overall revenue dropped to $235.9 million in July from $262.3 million in July 2007, the publisher said.

A continuing drop in classified ads and cutbacks in spending by movie studios, car companies and hotels were offset only partially by a rise in revenue from media, financial services, advocacy and health care ads for a net drop of 16.2 percent.

The company's flagship The New York Times paper had 15.3 percent lower ad revenue. At its New England media group, which includes The Boston Globe, July ad revenue dropped 24.5 percent.

Newspapers across the country have seen revenue decline as advertisers shift spending online and circulation slips.

Total online ad revenue rose 0.9 percent in the company's News Media Group, and circulation revenue fell 0.5 percent.

The company said its overall Internet revenue rose 2.6 percent with online ad revenue adding 5.5 percent, boosted by gains at its About.com Web site.

For the year to date, total revenue from continuing operations has fallen 6.1 percent to $1.73 billion.

12:22 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Senator Killpack of Davis County posted on the Senatesite today regarding Bernick's columnist-reporter two step.

I'm impressed that the two of you dare criticize him. But watch out, because payback is a bitch with Dirty Bernie.

6:58 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Why didn't Cannon clean house on these clowns when he had the chance at the last "layoffs?"

With quality reporting from the political team at the D-News its no wonder its circulation is in the dumps. How can it be trusted?

I stopped my subscription to the D-News after Davidson falsely trashed the scouting program earlier this year.

Question for Cannon: How do reporters like these support the new direction of "more local, more online, and more Mormon?"

12:09 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home