Thursday, July 19, 2007

Immigration: States Will Now Take the Reins

In the Education Committee yesterday, I suggested that we ask the federal government to reimburse Utah for the cost of educating children who are here illegally. (D News, Trib and Neil Cavuto – if anyone wants to grab that clip and email me it to me, steveu@infowest.com, I’d like to post it).

The Legislative Auditor estimates that Utah pays between 55- and 85-million dollars to educate children who are here illegally. That’s a lot of money for Utah (about 2 to 3 percent of the State’s expenditures for public education). According to federal law, Utah must educate these children no questions asked. If that’s the case, and if the federal government isn’t going to do anything about immigration, why shouldn’t the feds foot the education bill?

Now, I’m not holding my breath waiting for the check to show up, but I hope the conversation helps send the message that the states are going to move forward on immigration.

I have been one to encourage patience on immigration, reminding colleagues that the federal government has sole constitutional authority to deal with immigration. Like many state legislators, though, I have run out of patience with the ineptitude of our federal government on this issue. If they can’t deal with it, the States will.

States, after all, deal with most complex issues – education, crime, social services, transportation, etc. And, remember, every year (by what must appear to be powerful sorcery to our federal counterparts) states balance their budgets. Waiting on leadership from a group that can’t even balance its own checkbook is a tough thing for state legislators who year-in and year-out make the difficult decisions necessary to govern.

Given Congress’ recent failure to pass meaningful legislation – and fully realizing that Congress lacks the spine and/or ability to get back in the trenches and get the job done – I predict that most states will move forward on legislation to deal with impacts caused by illegal immigration. As Cavuto pointed out, it would be messy, if 50 states started doing their own thing on immigration. But, in my opinion, it’s probably better than doing nothing.

Suggestions?

40 Comments:

Blogger Reach Upward said...

OK, so it might be messy. Big deal. The Founders intended the states to be laboratories of democracy. Ideas were to bubble from the states up to the feds rather than being dictated by the feds to the states. On too many issues, we have gone the wrong direction for too long. Let us, by all means, start going back the other direction -- the way it was meant to be.

Yes, immigration is a national issue that demands federal action. Once the states experiment with solutions, we will get more of an idea of what works and what doesn't. Pressure will also mount for the feds to properly handle the matter.

It might seem like a funky way of doing things, given that we are so used to being given our marching orders from Washington, but let's get started.

5:03 PM  
Anonymous Andrew Parker said...

When will the Legislature request an audit of the benefits the State recieves from its illegal residents? What is their true value to the economy and to tax revenue? Are they a net profit or a net loss?

9:05 AM  
Anonymous grimalkin said...

Sounds like a good idea to me. Everything that we can do to focus attention and responsibility on this issue should be done. Our economy can't support all of the people who want to come here, there has to be limits. And if the economy collapses then no one will be helped.

9:50 AM  
Blogger steve u. said...

Andrew,

Correct. Sorry if my presentation was too one-sided.

As I said on Cavuto, we clearly do receive benefits from low-cost labor. However, it is a false perspective to recognize that simple economic fact and, then, jump to the conclusion that we should do nothing about illegal immigration. (I'm not saying that you are doing that, btw).

Personally, I am very in favor of generous immigration policy. But, we need to control who comes in and how they come in. We want to maximize the benefit and reduce the burden.

10:28 AM  
Blogger Nathan Daniels said...

The only problem is what cost will be placed on society, and ultimately the tax payers as those children begin turning to crime and gang related activity. As the saying goes, "an idle mind is the devil's playground."

There's also a legitimate debate to be held as to whether it is morally right to punish the children fo the sins of the parents.

The more money you get from the feds, the more control they exact. Lest we forget the lessons of NCLB, maybe there is a better way to send the message without gambling with our children's futures.

11:48 AM  
Blogger steve u. said...

Nathan,

I'd bet there is zero chance the feds will foot the bill or that states will stop educating the children. The point of the letter is to encourage the feds to get back in the ring and figure something out. States likely will lead out on non-education issues, like employment verification and welfare.

12:16 PM  
Blogger Misty Fowler said...

Has any research been done to check into how much the state gets back from the illegal immigrants? Some of them own houses, most pay taxes on their checks, all pay taxes on local purchases, etc.

I agree - get the feds talking again, but this seems like a weak bluff.

4:04 PM  
Anonymous Tim said...

Steve,

Of course this is a good idea. Any time the feds push an unfunded mandate onto us we should rebel.

I am concerned, however, that you have FOCUSED on the unfunded mandate of educating the children of illegal immigrants. This is actually one of the smallest unfunded mandates.

Special Education (regulated under IDEA) is only funded at about 40 percent of the cost each year. That adds up to a much larger unf. man. than the one you have mentioned.

Why have you chosen this one as your jumping off point?

6:47 PM  
Anonymous Andrew Parker said...

Rep. Urquhart,

For many years, I was under the impression that proof of citizenship or legal residence was required in order to receive Welfare and Medicaid assistance. I was a bit shocked to learn that the question is not asked. If true, is that mandated by the courts or is it an administrative decision?

Has the Mexican government been approached to set up health and welfare programs for their citizens here in the U.S.?

10:57 PM  
Blogger Craig said...

Have you looked at the 287(g) program, through which DHS trains local law enforcement to handle immigration violations, and also pitches in some money. That would be a good start for Utah.

5:33 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Welcome to our company which sells all kinds of cabal online alz.
You can buy and gain very cheap cabal alz.
And the more cheap cabal gold is very good for you.
If you have to buy cabal alz, please come to our company.
We can give you the best cabal money and best service.

10:18 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

When I see it, I feel that I just was going shopping. After a while, she took a nice pet and trade with her dofus kamas. My sister suggested me to buy dofus kamas first, and in this way we can explore more interesting things or funs. So after dealing with all the necessary things, I followed the way which my sister told me to use my a little real money to exchange some a little kamas to play firstly. After gaining a little dofus gold, I go shopping in the dofus game, there are full of all kinds of equipment and weapons. At last, I use my cheap kamas to buy a pet, which can accompany with me in my trip of dofus game.

11:21 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Delivering a new dimension for hardcore Maple Story players with the addition of a fourth job and some free maple mesos, this is launched today. Maple Story players will have reached a high enough level to achieve the 4th Job or some necessary maplestory mesos, which begins this week. Many people can cost their own cheap mesos to gain themed dessert and costumes among their many posts. The addition of the 4th Job provides further depth to an already intricate and complex maple story mesos in game. At Leafre, players find the new upgrades can receive from mesos and also party with other elite players.

8:00 PM  
Blogger game said...

Do you know rohan crone I like it.
My brother often go to the internet bar to buy rohan gold and play it.
After school, He likes playing games using these rohan online crone with his friend.
One day, he give me many rohan online gold and play the game with me.
I came to the bar following him and found rohan money was so cheap.

1:50 AM  
Anonymous nike shoes said...

nike shoes
nike shox
jordan shoes
puma shoes
nike dunks
nike air max
nike air force one
timberland boots
ugg boots
nike shoes
nike shox
nike air force 1
nike sb dunks
puma shoes
nike air max
jordan shoes
ugg boot
jordan sneakers
timberland shoes
bape shoes
nike shoes
nike shox
nike dunks
nike air force 1
jordan shoes

8:42 AM  
Anonymous nike shox said...

nike Air Force 1
nike shoes
Jordan shoes
nike sb dunks
cheap nike Air Force 1
cheap nike shoes
cheap Jordan shoes
cheap nike sb dunks
discount nike Air Force 1
discount nike shoes
discount Jordan shoes
discount nike sb dunks
nike shoes
nike shox
nike dunks
nike air force 1
jordan shoes
nike shoes
nike shox
nike dunks
nike air force 1
jordan shoes

8:49 AM  
Anonymous nike dunks said...

nike shoes
jordan shoes
nike dunks
nike air force 1
nike shox
nike shoes
nike shox
nike dunks
nike air force 1
nike shox
nike shoes
nike shox oz
nike shox nz
nike shox r3
nike shox r4
nike shox r5
nike shox tl

8:53 AM  
Anonymous cheap kids shoes said...

We are professional cheap kids shoes online store .We provide Nike shoes cheap ,Nike air jordan,cheap kids clothing,cheap womens clothing,Nike shoes online store,Nike shoes cheap,Nike shoes for kids,air jordan sneakers,nike air jordan,air jordans,brand shoe,shoes brand, dropship Nike shoes , brand clothes,brand clothes ,shoes brand,cheap kids clothing for cheap wholesale Air Jordans shoes for kids & women.

老虎机上分器,老虎机定位器,老虎机遥控器,老虎机破解,百乐2号破解,五星宏辉破解,单挑王破解,童装网,中国童装网,童装代理,童装品牌,童装新闻,sasa网购

9:12 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The network Gaia Gold layer - it will Dofus Kamas have to rely above, so Gaia Online Gold no need to trouble Kamas Dofus with the sockets. Use the top Kamas layer for your Buy Gaia Online Gold platform, even a library Acheter des Kamas full client-server. The graphics Buy Gaia Gold library - Do not write your Dofus Kamas Pas Cher scene graph, wretch! Neither the routines to MMORPG News load resources (images, 3D models). From the little I know Gold Gaia of DirectX is probably used Gaia Money directly, but for OpenGl, find Buy Gaia Money yourself a good graphics engine. ADH uses Gaia OpenSceneGraph, but there Gaia Gold Store are tons in all languages.

12:46 AM  
Blogger freefun0616 said...

酒店經紀人, 菲梵酒店經紀, 酒店經紀, 禮服酒店上班, 酒店小姐兼職, 便服酒店經紀, 酒店打工經紀, 制服酒店工作, 專業酒店經紀, 合法酒店經紀, 酒店暑假打工, 酒店寒假打工, 酒店經紀人, 菲梵酒店經紀, 酒店經紀, 禮服酒店上班, 酒店經紀人, 菲梵酒店經紀, 酒店經紀, 禮服酒店上班, 酒店小姐兼職, 便服酒店工作, 酒店打工經紀, 制服酒店經紀, 專業酒店經紀, 合法酒店經紀, 酒店暑假打工, 酒店寒假打工, 酒店經紀人, 菲梵酒店經紀, 酒店經紀, 禮服酒店上班, 酒店小姐兼職, 便服酒店工作, 酒店打工經紀, 制服酒店經紀,,

4:35 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ed Hardy
Ed Hardy Women Swimwear
Ed Hardy Women T-Shirts
ED Hardy womens Hoodies
ED Hardy Womens Jeans
Ed Hardy Womens Lingerie
ED Hardy Womens Shoes
Ed Hardy Womens Tanks
ED Hardy womens Tops
Ed Hardy Men T-Shirts
ED Hardy Mens Hoodies
ED Hardy Mens Jeans
Ed Hardy Mens Shoes
Ed Hardy Mens Swim Trunks
Ed Hardy Mens Tops
ED Hardy Mens Underwear
ED Hardy Caps
Ed Hardy Sunglasses
Ed Hardy Belts
Ed Hardy Wallets
tiffany jewelry
Ed Hardy Bags
Discount Christian Louboutin shoes
Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes
Christian Louboutin Shoes sale
Christian louboutin wedding shoes
Buy Christian louboutin shoes
Christian Louboutin Boots
Cheap Christian Louboutin Boots

9:01 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Fake-designer.com manufactures replicaLouis Vuitton that are indistinguishable from the latest sensations to come out of France. From the chic and modern Monogram Perfo to the classic Louis Vuitton Wallets, our fake
Louis Vuitton Handbags are perfect imitations, indistinguishable from the real thing.
Our replica Luis Vuitton collection includes everything; Monogram Perfo Pochettes, compact wallets and Speedy satchels can be yours for below-market prices when you buy from Fake-designer.com. The same goes for each and every item in our Louie Vuitton lines- from our Louis Vuitton Bags to our Fendi handbags. If you love Cheap Louis Vuitton, ,designer Replica Louis Vuitton;Fake-designer.com has something for you.
All of our fake Louis Vuitton Outlet are made to look and feel just like the originals. No one will be able to tell you’re carrying one of our fake Louis Vuitton Sale, because our imitation Louis Vuitton Online Saleare identical to the real thing.

1:18 AM  
Blogger feng said...

Thanks for your useful info, I think it’s a good topic. So would you like the info about the
jordan shoes
Air jordan shoes
cardy ugg boots
ugg bailey button boots
cheap jordan shoes
ugg boots uk
Michael jordan shoes
ugg london
ugg nightfall boots
ugg boots sale
classic ugg boots
sundance ugg boots
air jordan fusion 6
air jordan 6 rings
Tiffany Jewelry
jordan shoes for sale

9:41 PM  
Anonymous Rolex Datejust watches said...

Montblanc watch for sale
movado watch for sale
omega watch for sale
oris watch for sale
Patek Philippe watch for sale
Piaget watch for sale
Rado watch for sale
Tag Heuer watch for sale
Tudor watch for sale
U-boat watch for sale
Vacheron Constantin watch for sale
Rolex watch for sale
Rolex Air-King watch for sale
Rolex Datejust II watch for sale

10:41 AM  
Anonymous replica Bvlgari said...

replica Cartier
replica chopard
replica Concord
replica croum
replica DeWitt
replica ebel
replica Ferrari
replica Franck Muller
replica Glashutte
replica Graham
replica Hermes

10:42 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Panerai watch for sale
Patek Philippe watch for sale
Piaget watch for sale
Rado watch for sale
Tag Heuer watch for sale
Tudor watch for sale
U-boat watch for sale
Vacheron Constantin watch for sale
Rolex watch for sale
Rolex Air-King watch for sale

8:38 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

fake

Tiffany Rings replica

Tiffany Pendants replica

Tiffany Earrings replica

Tiffany Necklaces replica

Tiffany Heart replica

Tiffany 1837 replica

9:42 AM  
Anonymous chopard watches said...

watches
A.Lange & Sohne watches
Audemars Piguet watches
Bell & Ross watches
Breguet watches
Breitling watches
Burberry watches
Bvlgari watches
Cartier watches

5:13 PM  
Anonymous chopard watches said...

A.Lange & Sohne watches
Audemars Piguet watches
Bell & Ross watches
Breguet watches
Breitling watches
Burberry watches
Burberry watches
Bvlgari watches
Cartier watches

5:14 PM  
Anonymous A.Lange & Sohne watch for sale said...

Rolex Air-King watches
Rolex Datejust II watches
Rolex Datejust watches
Rolex Submariner watches
Yachtmaster watches
Rolex Day-Date II watches
Rolex Daytona watches
Rolex Explorer watches
Rolex GMT watches
Rolex Sea-Dweller watches
Rolex Day Date watches
Rolex Masterpiece watches
Rolex Milgauss watches

5:22 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Patek Philippe watch for sale
Piaget watch for sale
Rado watch for sale
Tag Heuer watch for sale

8:37 AM  
Anonymous discount Christian Louboutin Sandals said...

discount Christian Louboutin Shoes
discount Christian Louboutin Pumps
discount Christian Louboutin Boots
discount Christian Louboutin Pumps
discount Christian Louboutin Sandals
discount Christian Louboutin Shoes

11:23 AM  
Anonymous Christian Louboutin Slingbacks on sale said...

CChristian Louboutin Slingbacks
cheap Christian Louboutin Slingbacks
discount Christian Louboutin Slingbacks
Christian Louboutin Slingbacks on sale

8:03 AM  
Anonymous Manolo Blahnik said...

Alexander McQueen on sale
Chloe on sale
Christian Louboutin Boots on sale
Christian Louboutin Boots on sale
Christian Louboutin Evening on sale
Christian Louboutin Pumps on sale
Christian Louboutin Sandals on sale
Christian Louboutin Wedges on sale
Jimmy Choo on sale
on sale Manolo Blahnik
SnowboardBoots / Vancl on sal
Tiffany Silver Jewelry on sale

5:45 PM  
Anonymous Cartier said...

A.Lange & Sohne
Bell & Ross
Breguet
Breitling
Bvlgari
Cartier

7:26 AM  
Anonymous discount Christian Louboutin Boot said...

Christian Louboutin Boot
Christian Louboutin Pump
Christian Louboutin sandal
Jimmy Choo Handbags
Jimmy Choo Shoes
Yves Saint Laurent Shoes



cheap Christian Louboutin Boot

11:35 AM  
Anonymous discount nba jersey sale said...

If a man join together to pursuit knowledge, no one can take it from him.cheap nfl jersys Books are to human beings which as nba jerseys sale emory to the individuanl nhl Jerseys.We cannot change anything mlb jerseys unless we learn and accept it, Damn does not liberate it, it oppresses.A classic adidas jerseys book which people praise but don't read.A man dies still if he has done nothing, as one who has done football child jerseys much.Education is something which remains ofter one has forgotten everything football jerseys he learned in school.Education is something remains ofter one has forgotten everything he learned in school.http://www.nfljerseymlb.com/

11:18 PM  
Anonymous uggs perfect chrismas gift said...

Sorrow is peace in my heart like the ugg 5806 boots evening among the tall upside lace uggs silent trees.if you tears when you miss the ugg 5817 style boots sun, you will also miss the ugg 5281 kid boots stars.her eager ugg 5819 fur boots face bothers my ugg 5842 classic boots dreams as the ugg 30th anniversary rain at ugg 5691 lo pro button night.once we dreamt that we were ugg 5202 infant's erin strangers. when we wake up we find that we were to love each other's.http://www.uggboots4buy.com/

11:18 PM  
Anonymous Hublot watches said...

chopard watch for sale
Concord watch for sale
croum watch for sale
DeWitt watch for sale
ebel watch for sale
Ferrari watch for sale
Franck Muller watch for sale
Glashutte watch for saleebel watches
Ferrari watches
Franck Muller watches
Glashutte watches
Graham watches
Hermes watches
Hublot watches

11:19 AM  
Anonymous replica Rolex Sea-Dweller said...

replica watches
Ferrari watch for sale
Hublot replica
oris replica
Hermes watches
replica Rolex

12:35 PM  

<< Home